How To Know What Kind of Editing You Need

size for Blog images (5)

Nearly done with your fiction manuscript?

Take a breath. Inhale … exhale. You’ve done the hard work of drafting and revising and now comes the stage of making informed choices about editing. This isn’t about judging whether your story is “good.” It’s about understanding what kind of support fits your manuscript and what steps come next.

The Types of Editing

Even if you’re not hiring an editor yet, knowing the industry lingo helps.

Developmental / Structural Editing
Big-picture work: plot, pacing, character arcs, story structure, and whether the book holds together as a whole. This kind of editing usually happens earlier in the process, before sentence-level refinement and final polish.

Line Editing
Sentence-level attention to tone, rhythm, clarity, and flow—making the writing feel intentional and smooth.

Copyediting
Grammar, punctuation, word choice, and consistency—cleaning up the mechanics so nothing distracts the reader.

Proofreading
The final check for typos, formatting issues, and small errors before publication.

Optional / Specialized Edits
Sensitivity reads, fact-checking, or genre-specific reviews, depending on the book.

You don’t need all of these. And you don’t need to figure it out alone. But before you hand over your money, understand the differences, and you’ll make informed choices instead of guessing.

Signs You and Your Manuscript Are Ready for an Editor

“Ready” doesn’t mean finished or perfect. It looks more like this:

  • You’ve revised as much as you reasonably can on your own, and further tinkering isn’t bringing clarity.
  • You can feel that something needs attention, but you’re too close to the manuscript to see it clearly anymore.
  • You want to be sure your writing—sentence by sentence—is clear, consistent, and doing the work you intend it to do.
  • You want professional guidance to help you understand what stage your manuscript is truly in.

That’s not failure. That’s discernment.

A Little Extra Help

No forms. No pressure. Just a practical tool to help you think things through before you spend money or commit to a next step.

Being ready for an editor isn’t about being “done.”
It’s about knowing which next steps make sense for your manuscript and choosing support that matches this stage of the process.

Asking these questions doesn’t mean your work isn’t good. It means you’re taking your book—and your readers—seriously and means you care enough to make sure readers see it at its very best.

images of me - website (1080 x 1350 px) (1)

About the Author


Susan is the editor behind Fine Line Proofs, where she spends her days happily reading fiction manuscripts and obsessing over commas.

She works with fiction writers whose stories are nearly ready—the exciting (and slightly nerve-wracking) stage when a manuscript is finished, but they just need to know it’s right before sending it to agents or readers.

When she’s not editing, Susan is usually digging in her garden, planning a home project, or writing slightly mischievous children’s stories about life on her farm.

If you feel like talking through your manuscript, message her here, she’s always happy to chat. She also shares occasional reflections in her newsletter, Coffee Talk with Susan, where she talks about editing and the questions writers often ask.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *